We’ve all experienced that unmistakable plunk, a flush and panic. Whether it’s a ring, a phone or toys in the toilet, a stuck object can mean clogs, overflows or even cracks.
Fortunately, with a few smart steps, you can often retrieve the item — or at least protect your plumbing until help arrives.
This guide walks you through safe, step-by-step foreign object removal for toilets and explains exactly when to stop and call a pro.
A Quick Plumbing Lesson
Toilets have three key parts — the bowl, trap and drainpipe. The trap is the curved part at the base of the toilet. It holds water to block sewer gases and is often where foreign objects get stuck. Most DIY retrievals focus here.
Step 1: Stop the Flush
If something has gone down the toilet, don’t flush again. Flushing toys or other objects down the toilet will push them deeper and raise the risk of damage. If water is rising, turn the shut-off valve at the base of the toilet clockwise to stop the flow.
Step 2: Gather Your Supplies
Have the following ready:
- Rubber gloves
- Bucket
- Plunger
- Toilet auger or plumbing snake
- Towels or rags for spills
In place of an auger, some homeowners try bending a wire coat hanger into a hook. This option can scratch porcelain or push the object further, so it’s better to call a professional.
Step 3: Try the Plunger
Place the plunger over the toilet drain opening and create a firm seal. Press down gently, then pull back steadily to create pressure and try to dislodge the object. Repeat a few times.
Plunging works best on small, light or soft items. If the bowl drains slowly or water rises, switch methods.
Step 4: Use a Toilet Auger
Insert the auger tip into the drain and slowly crank it through the trap. When you feel resistance, rotate to snag or break up the obstruction, then pull back carefully. To avoid jamming the object deeper, don’t force the tool.
Step 5: Know When to Call a Plumber
DIY plumbing has limits. Call a professional if:
- The object is out of reach or won’t budge.
- You’re not comfortable using a plunger or auger.
- The toilet overflows, won’t stop running or drains very slowly.
- You suspect a crack or leak.
- Multiple attempts haven’t worked.
Whether you need drain cleaning, toilet repair or even replacement, FLAME Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electrical has you covered. Our team has the tools and expertise to handle even the toughest clogs without damaging your plumbing.
Call FLAME Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electrical to Remove Toys and Foreign Objects From the Toilet
If you’ve taken the right steps and the item still won’t come out — or you suspect damage — it’s time to call for help.
FLAME Heating, Cooling, Plumbing & Electrical’s licensed plumbers handle fast, no-damage toilet object removal and drain cleaning. Contact us for a free in-home estimate today.
Last Updated on October 10, 2025 at 12:40PM EST
